• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

ANNIE’S PIZZA - Crossville: Handmade, Flavorful Pizza Hidden in a Gas Station

ANNIE’S PIZZA - Crossville is a hidden gem tucked inside a gas station at 5461 Peavine Rd, TN. Don’t let the unassuming location fool you—each pizza is handmade with care, boasting rich, flavorful sauce and perfectly balanced toppings. Customers rave about their authentic, restaurant-quality pies, like the standout BBQ chicken and classic pepperoni. The breadsticks are soft and well-seasoned, complementing the tasty marinara sauce. Service is warm and friendly, creating a welcoming vibe despite the minimalist setting. For anyone seeking genuine, satisfying pizza away from commercial chains, ANNIE’S PIZZA delivers a remarkable and affordable experience.

ANNIE’S PIZZA - Crossville at a glance

  • Address 5461 Peavine Rd, Crossville, TN 38571, United States
  • Phone +1 931-456-2222
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner .

Photos & Gallery

ANNIE’S PIZZA - Crossville: Reviews & Ratings

John Michael
5

Tell you what! You wouldn't expect to find some great restaurant quality pizza. And really, it beats most of the local pizza places. And when it comes to being a REAL pizza, it's the closest I've had in a long time! It's not a place to sit and eat with ambiance as it's a gas station, but damn!!! That pizza was great! We also had some of those awesome breadsticks. They were soft, full and not all air inside, flavored perfectly. Oh, and their marinara sauce was tasty too. Everyone in there has always been super friendly and great to talk with. A must go to for pizza and breadsticks! Hopefully everything else too!!!! Great job guys!!

monica nyi
5

Annie, Annie, Annie! I was practically preaching her name as I was eating this filling and delicious pizza. A very unassuming (almost scary) location however, the pizza was worthwhile. I even feel as if the atmosphere adds to the tastiness of the flavor explosion we call Annie’s Pizza. It was my pleasure to experience this cuisine.

Harrison Jones
5

The best pizza in Fairfield Glade. This hole in the wall place is built into the gas station. Each pizza is handmade and always delicious. Highly recommend the BBQ chicken.

Jess West
5

The calzone was delicious! Sam was friendly as always!

Joseph
5

To be honest, it was a bit suspect as it was in a gas station… however I ordered five pizzas and every last one of them was phenomenal. The sauce was the absolute hero of the meal. The overall cost is fairly on par with the main chains however, given the quality of the food, I think it is absolutely worth it. I would pick this place over any main chain pizza restaurant 10 out of 10. Order: 2x Pepperoni 1x meats 1x Hawaiian 1x cheese

Location

  • ANNIE’S PIZZA - Crossville
    ANNIE’S PIZZA - Crossville
    5461 Peavine Rd, Crossville, TN 38571, United States Hotline: +1 931-456-2222

Nestled unassumingly within a gas station at 5461 Peavine Rd, Crossville, TN, ANNIE’S PIZZA defies expectations with its truly exceptional, handmade pies. From the first bite, it's clear this is no ordinary pizza joint. The crust strikes a perfect balance—neither too thick nor thin—offering a satisfying chew that complements the fresh, flavorful toppings. The sauce shines as the true hero here: rich, tangy, and vibrant, it elevates every slice, from classic pepperoni to the standout BBQ chicken, which comes highly recommended by locals.

The array of offerings doesn’t stop at pizza. Their breadsticks deserve a dedicated nod—soft, full-bodied, and rightly seasoned, they come paired with a marinara sauce that’s just as meticulously crafted, boasting bold yet balanced flavors. The calzone, too, impresses with its generous fillings and perfectly baked dough, making each bite a warm, comforting delight.

While the atmosphere is modest—more functional than fancy—the effortless warmth and genuine friendliness of the staff create a welcoming, down-to-earth vibe that complements the food's authenticity. It’s a classic example of substance over style, where taste reigns supreme.

ANNIE’S PIZZA stands as a local gem that consistently beats chain pizzerias in both flavor and quality. Whether you’re craving a pepperoni, meats, Hawaiian, or a simple cheese pizza, each pie is crafted with care and soul. This spot proves that greatness can be found in the most unexpected places, delivering hearty, satisfying meals that keep diners coming back for more.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards